Ariel HaNaviy Supporter Messianic Jew and Torah Teacher with Messianic Congregation 'The Harvest'

“For freedom Christ has set us free; stand firm therefore, and do not submit again to a yoke of slavery.” (Gal. 5:1)

What exactly IS the slavery that Paul speaks of here? To be “in Messiah” is to be truly free (recall Yeshua’s (Jesus’) declaration from John 8:36, “If the Son therefore shall make you free, ye shall be free indeed” (KJV). How is then that these Galatian Gentiles wish to return to the slavery that marked their former manner of life? Can’t they see that anything less than a complete commitment to the true Gospel is not good news at all, and will eventually result in slavery?

As is to be expected, historic Christianity interprets the slavery of verse one as a return to Judaism, a return to living in the confines of Torah (Law) observance, a return to Sabbaths, keeping kosher, keeping the Feasts, and of course, circumcision. However, when we go back and study the historical and sociological context of the book of Galatians more closely, we will discover that the standard Christian interpretation of this verse does not fit with Paul’s view of Torah, and most importantly, it does it follow from the Scriptural view of Torah. The Torah is not bondage. However, if one places their trust in ethnicity and/or Torah obedience, then that person is truly a slave to their old nature—whether they know it or not. 

The battle lines were being drawn, not between the relevance of Torah vs. The relevance of Yeshua. The lines were being drawn between the necessity of Jewish identity for covenant inclusion vs. The necessity of falling on the mercy and grace of Messiah for genuine covenant membership and forgiveness of sins. Paul doesn't need to denigrate the Torah by calling it a yoke of slavery because that is not the focus of the argument in the first place. As we shall see in the next verse (needed to develop the context of verse one), circumcision is the fulcrum by which membership into 1st century Isra'el was being weighed.

The Galatian Gentiles were at the crossroads of decision. Would they invest their faith in Jewish ethnicity? Or would they invest their faith in Jesus Christ— the one who died and rose again? In Gal. 2:21, the contest in the mind of the Galatians used the verbiage of Christ vs. The Law. Here in Gal. 5:2, the contest uses the verbiage of Christ vs. Circumcision. After studying the Jewish background to Paul’s life and knowing his propensity for carefully reasoned arguments, it should be amply clear that Paul did not mean Torah observance when he used the word “Law” in Gal. 2:21. By the same token, it should be amply clear that he does not simply mean physical circumcision when he uses the word “circumcision” in Gal. 5:2. 

Conclusions:
In Gal. 5:1, 2 (as well as Gal. 2:21 from earlier), Paul states that if the Galatians wish to continue down the road constructed by those false teachers—the road described by the 1st century Judaisms as “the law,” “under the law,” works of the law,” and “circumcision,”—and reject the free offer of genuine and lasting covenant membership into Isra'el as offered by God and outlined in the TaNaKH (OT), then (using the language of Gal. 5:1, 2) the work done by Yeshua’s cross will indeed have no value for them at all.

Biblical freedom does not mean free from Law. Again, knowing that Yeshua set us free from sin, its proclivities, its bondage, and its ultimate penalty, helps us to understand Paul’s teachings on this subject. The paradigm set by the Exodus narrative teaches us that sin (bondage) prevents us from truly worshiping God the way he deserves to be worshipped. Speaking for God, Moses said, “Let my people go so that they may serve me!” Once Yeshua makes us alive in him and sets us free indeed, we are then free to worship God properly without the fear of condemnation or bondage to sin. This means we are free to walk into Torah the way God intended it to be walked out: in imitation of Messiah, by the Spirit, and to the glory of God the Father.

September 06 2015 • 2 responses • Vote Up • Share • Report

S. Michael Houdmann Supporter Got Questions Ministries

Christian liberty is found in the Bible in several concepts. For example, liberty for the Christian can mean that he or she has been freed from the penalty of sin by faith in Jesus Christ (John 8:3...

Login or Sign Up to view the rest of this answer.

July 01 2013 • 0 responses • Vote Up • Share • Report

James Kraft Supporter 74 year old retired pipeline worker

Many of those things brother Michael has stated are the doctrines of men spoken of in Colossians 2: 20-23. Why do you obey the doctines of men, touch not, taste not, smell not, the rudiments of the world. Many of our churches have degenerated into law keeping for salvation much like the Pharisees of old. We make up these extra biblical laws and make them binding on everyone. 

My son calls them the "super apostles". I call them being spiritually correct. The doctrines of men never replace Gods laws. It puts people in bondage to rules and regulations on the one hand, and leads some people to hell believing that obeying these extra biblical rules is what saves them. 

We are not to add anything to Gods word and are not to take away anything from it. We jump all over the liberals who change the truth of God for a lie, but when us "super saints" do it it is OK. 

And Jesus said there would be prostitutes in heaven before them. They are the ones Jesus was talking about that would come to Him and say "Lord Lord' Did we not prophesy in your name and even cast out demons. And Jesus will say,"depart from me I never knew you". They trusted in their own righteousness to save them by obeying their own laws.

Jesus paid an awful price for our sins so that we could go to heaven by just believing that all of our sins are nailed to that cross and washed away in His blood. If you want to go to heaven put your faith in Jesus alone without works and you will be saved. Then Jesus comes into our lives and works in us and thru us to do what we cannot do.

September 30 2015 • 3 responses • Vote Up • Share • Report